Carrier review

Farmers

Best for owners of classic cars or specialty vehicles who want agent guidance

73Critic Farm Score
Price65

Farmers' agent-driven, multi-brand structure tends to keep pricing moderate rather than aggressively low.

Claims experience68

Claims satisfaction has historically been more mixed in industry feedback compared with some larger direct competitors.

Digital tools70

The Farmers app and Signal safe-driving program have improved in recent years but still lag the digital polish of more direct-first insurers.

Coverage options84

Specialty options for classic cars and other niche vehicles give Farmers a real edge for less conventional coverage needs.

Overview

Farmers has built a long-standing identity around its agent network and, notably, around specialization — the company and its agents are frequently associated with expertise in niche coverage areas like classic cars, motorcycles, and RVs, which can be a real advantage for owners of unusual vehicles who want someone who actually understands the risk. Over the years Farmers has also grown through acquiring other brands (including names like 21st Century and Bristol West), giving it a multi-brand structure that can serve different risk profiles under one corporate umbrella, though it can also make comparing Farmers' pricing directly with other carriers a little less straightforward. Its agent-driven model provides a personal touch similar to State Farm or Allstate, but Farmers has generally been more moderate than aggressive on price — not a standout bargain, but not typically the priciest option either. Claims satisfaction feedback has historically been more mixed relative to some larger direct competitors, and its digital tools, while improved through the Farmers app and its Signal safe-driving program, still feel like they're catching up to more digital-native insurers rather than leading. Farmers is a reasonable choice for drivers who want dedicated agent attention, particularly for less conventional vehicles.

Strengths

  • Strong agent relationships and specialty vehicle expertise
  • Good options for classic cars, RVs, and other niche vehicles
  • Meaningful discounts for bundling multiple policies
  • Long-standing national and regional presence
  • Multiple owned brands offer flexibility across different risk profiles

Weaknesses

  • Claims satisfaction has been more mixed in some industry feedback
  • Digital tools have historically lagged top competitors
  • Pricing is moderate rather than a standout value

Availability

Available in most states directly and through agents; specific coverage options and affiliated brand offerings vary by region.

How to read this score

Scores reflect Critic Farm's editorial assessment based on publicly known company characteristics, not a scientific survey. Verify current rates, coverage, and terms directly with the insurer.

See if Farmers fits your profile

Run the match →